CAN YOUR HANDS KNOW SOMETHING YOUR BRAIN DOESN’T?
A sushi dinner in Bangkok raises a question about touch, tacit knowledge and whether everything a skilled cook knows can be put into words.
One of the best sushi dinners of my life took place in a small restaurant on the first floor of a building in Bangkok, a place I would never have discovered by accident. I sat at the counter while the chef prepared one piece after another: sea bream, amberjack, tuna, sea urchin and, eventually, unagi — grilled eel so delicious that I asked for another piece. I had eaten excellent sushi in Tokyo and Europe, but something about this evening was extraordinary. The quality of the fish, the atmosphere, the quiet concentration of the chef. And I found myself wondering about his hands. How does a sushi chef know exactly how firmly to press the rice? Too little pressure and the nigiri falls apart. Too much and it becomes a compact lump. Somewhere between those extremes lies a delicate structure that holds together just long enough to reach your mouth.
In 2024, Japanese researchers compared sushi rice shaped by professional chefs with rice shaped by machines. They even used X-ray imaging to examine the tiny spaces between individual grains. Surprisingly, some measurements showed little difference between handmade and machine-made sushi. But under pressure, the rice behaved differently. Another Japanese study suggested that the arrangement of individual rice grains influences how the sushi feels when we chew it. Imagine that: the arrangement of individual grains of rice, something most of us have never considered while enjoying a piece of nigiri. Yet an experienced chef may influence this intricate structure through movements refined over thousands of repetitions, without consciously calculating what each finger should do.
Scientists call this tacit knowledge: knowing how to do something without necessarily being able to explain exactly how. Think of a pianist whose fingers find the right keys, a cyclist who maintains balance without understanding the equations of motion, or a grandmother who knows that her dough needs another handful of flour without ever measuring it. Of course, the brain is involved. Our hands don’t possess an independent intelligence. But some knowledge develops through the constant interaction of movement, touch, perception and experience. You can explain how to ride a bicycle in considerable detail, yet no amount of explanation will teach someone to balance on two wheels. The body has to learn something that words alone cannot convey.
And this is where artificial intelligence enters the kitchen. AI can explain the science of sushi rice, describe the movements of a master chef and generate remarkably precise instructions. Machines can already form nigiri, and there is no reason to assume they will never reproduce the finest details of a human chef’s technique. But describing a skill and possessing it are different things. A recipe tells us what to do; a skilled cook responds to what is happening while doing it. I still remember that evening in Bangkok, particularly the extraordinary care with which each piece was prepared and served. I wonder how many thousands of nigiri the chef had made before preparing mine, and how much of what he knew he could actually explain. Perhaps the most interesting question isn’t whether our hands know something our brains don’t, but whether everything we know can be put into words.
The restaurant: Sushi Sekiji, Thaniya Road, Bangkok.