CAN AI TELL A STORY THAT NEVER HAPPENED?
A woman who never tasted a tomato. A podcast that never existed. And an AI that invented both.
Yesterday, I searched Google for my new podcast, I Have Never Tasted a Tomato. I wanted to see whether the search engine had discovered our website. Instead, Google’s AI introduced me to Zorrie, an artist who had supposedly spent the first thirty years of her life unable to eat tomatoes because of a rare allergy. According to Google, she was now undergoing a medical treatment that would finally allow her to taste a tomato for the first time. Her journey, naturally, was being documented in a podcast called I Have Never Tasted a Tomato. It sounded wonderful. A moving story about food, science, memory and the anticipation of a taste never experienced. There was just one problem: Zorrie didn’t exist. Neither did her allergy, her treatment or her podcast. When I asked Google whether it had invented the whole thing, it cheerfully admitted that it had.
What fascinates me is not simply that an AI got something wrong. It created an entire human experience out of a few words. A woman, a childhood without tomatoes, a medical breakthrough, the suspense of a first taste. It understood what would make the story compelling. And perhaps that’s where things become interesting. Humans invent stories all the time. We call it fiction, imagination, creativity. When a novelist invents a woman who has never tasted a tomato, we might admire the result. When a search engine does the same thing while pretending to report facts, we call it a hallucination. The difference is not necessarily in the story itself, but in the relationship between the storyteller and the audience. Are we being invited to imagine something, or being asked to believe it?
Somewhere in Google’s imagination, a woman named Zorrie has just tasted her first tomato. She doesn’t exist. Her allergy doesn’t exist. Her podcast doesn’t exist. But the story is surprisingly moving. And somewhere else, a real human is preparing a podcast with an artificial intelligence that has never tasted a tomato. That AI can describe the sweetness, acidity and aroma of a ripe tomato. It can invent recipes, suggest surprising combinations and write stories about people who taste one for the first time. But it has never experienced any of those things. Perhaps the most interesting question isn’t whether AI can tell a good story. It’s what happens when we forget who, or what, is telling it. At least, we think we’re real.